Comparative Analysis of Leading Nonprofit Software Solutions
By Unknown Author | Published: 2024-01-01 | Category: Nonprofit Software
About Nonprofit Software
Nonprofit software encompasses tools designed specifically to help charitable organizations manage operations, including donor relations, fundraising, marketing, accounting, and program management. These platforms streamline workflows and enhance engagement to support mission-driven activities.
Scoring Criteria
- → Ease of Use
- → CRM/Donor Management Features
- → Fundraising Capabilities
- → Reporting & Analytics
- → Integration Options
- → Customer Support
- → Value for Money
The Best Nonprofit Software
#11
Fundraise Up
By Fundraise Up
AI-powered online fundraising platform focused on optimizing the donation experience and maximizing conversion rates.
Platforms & Use Cases
Platforms: Web-based
Best For: Online Donations, Recurring Giving Programs, Checkout Optimization, Mobile Wallet Donations
Key Features
- ✓AI-Powered Checkout: Optimizes donation forms and ask amounts in real-time.
- ✓Elements Modal: Modern, quick-loading donation overlay activated by site buttons.
- ✓Recurring Giving Optimization: Features designed to boost monthly donor conversion and retention.
- ✓Mobile Wallet Support: Supports Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal, Venmo.
- ✓Donor Portal: Allows donors to manage their recurring gifts and details.
Scorecard (Overall: 7.7 / 10.0)
Pricing
Standard (Fee-Based)
Contact Vendor
- All Core Features
- AI Optimization
- Unlimited Donations
- Integrations
Limitations: Platform fee per transaction (can be covered by donor)
Custom
Contact Vendor
- Volume Pricing
- Dedicated Support
- Advanced Customization
Limitations: For high-volume organizations
Pros
- + Excellent user experience for donors
- + Proven to increase online donations
- + Modern technology (AI, mobile wallets)
- + Easy setup and integration
- + No upfront platform cost
Cons
- - Primarily focused on online donation processing, not a full CRM
- - Relies on integrations for donor management
- - Transaction fees apply (though can be donor-covered)
Verdict
"An outstanding platform for optimizing online donations and recurring giving, best used alongside a dedicated CRM for full donor management."
Network for Good
By Network for Good (Acquired by Bonterra)
Provides simple, integrated software for fundraising, donor management, and communication, targeted at small nonprofits.
Platforms & Use Cases
Platforms: Web-based
Best For: Donor Management, Online Fundraising, Email Communication, Event Management, Peer-to-Peer Fundraising
Key Features
- ✓All-in-One Simplicity: Combines essential fundraising and CRM tools in one package.
- ✓Personal Fundraising Coach: Offers access to coaching services (often included in plans).
- ✓Donation Pages: Easy-to-create online giving forms.
- ✓Email & Communication Tools: Basic tools for sending emails and acknowledgments.
- ✓Event Ticketing: Simple event registration and management features.
Scorecard (Overall: 6.7 / 10.0)
Pricing
All-in-One Fundraising Software
$200.00 / Monthly
- Donor Management
- Unlimited Donation Pages
- Email Tools
- Event Ticketing
- Personal Coach
Limitations: Starts at this price point, can increase, Feature set is less comprehensive than larger platforms
Pros
- + Very easy to use
- + Good value for included features and coaching
- + Designed specifically for small nonprofits
- + Integrated core functionalities
Cons
- - Limited customization and reporting capabilities
- - Fewer integrations than competitors
- - Less scalable for complex needs
- - Part of Bonterra, potential changes
Verdict
"A strong contender for small nonprofits seeking an easy-to-use, all-in-one solution with integrated coaching support, but may be outgrown."
#9
Givebutter
By Givebutter
Free fundraising platform offering diverse tools like donations, events, and auctions, with optional CRM capabilities.
Platforms & Use Cases
Platforms: Web-based
Best For: Online Donations, Event Ticketing, Peer-to-Peer Fundraising, Auctions, Basic CRM
Key Features
- ✓Multiple Fundraising Tools: Supports donation forms, campaigns, events, auctions, P2P.
- ✓Free Platform (Tip-Based): Platform use is free; relies on optional donor tips. Low fixed transaction fees.
- ✓Engage CRM: Built-in (optional) CRM for tracking donors and engagement.
- ✓Ease of Use: Simple setup and user-friendly interface for campaigns.
- ✓Team Fundraising: Supports individual and team peer-to-peer fundraising.
Scorecard (Overall: 7.9 / 10.0)
Pricing
Free
Contact Vendor
- All Fundraising Tools
- Unlimited Campaigns
- Unlimited Contacts
- Standard Support
Limitations: Relies on optional donor tips; standard payment processing fees apply (e.g., Stripe/PayPal)
Platform Fee Option
Contact Vendor
- All Fundraising Tools
- Ability to disable donor tips and pay a platform fee instead
Limitations: Platform fee percentage applied per transaction if tips disabled
Pros
- + Free platform option (tip-based)
- + Wide range of modern fundraising tools
- + Very easy to use
- + Excellent for events and P2P
- + Transparent transaction fees
Cons
- - CRM features are less robust than dedicated CRMs
- - Reporting is basic
- - Relies heavily on integrations for advanced marketing
Verdict
"An exceptional choice for organizations prioritizing modern fundraising tools (especially events/P2P) with minimal platform cost. Best suited for those whose CRM needs are basic or met elsewhere."
#8
Keela
By Keela
Integrated nonprofit software combining CRM, email marketing, fundraising, and reporting with AI-powered insights.
Platforms & Use Cases
Platforms: Web-based
Best For: Donor Management, Email Marketing, Online Donations, Reporting, Grant Management, Volunteer Management
Key Features
- ✓Smart Ask (AI): Suggests optimal donation ask amounts based on donor history.
- ✓Integrated Email Marketing: Build, send, and track email campaigns within the platform.
- ✓Donation Forms: Create customizable online donation pages.
- ✓Contact Segmentation: Tools for grouping contacts based on various criteria.
- ✓Impact Reporting: Track key performance indicators and fundraising success.
Scorecard (Overall: 7.1 / 10.0)
Pricing
Starter
$119.00 / Monthly
- Up to 1,000 Contacts
- CRM
- Email Marketing
- Donation Forms
Limitations: Limited contacts, Fewer advanced features
Pro
$239.00 / Monthly
- Up to 2,500 Contacts
- Peer-to-Peer
- Grant Management
- AI Features
Limitations: Contact-based pricing
Pros
- + User-friendly interface
- + Integrated core tools
- + Innovative AI features
- + Good customer support
Cons
- - Fewer integrations compared to some competitors
- - Reporting could be more robust
- - AI features still evolving
Verdict
"A modern, user-friendly option, particularly appealing for nonprofits interested in leveraging AI for fundraising optimization within an integrated platform."
#7
Virtuous
By Virtuous Software
Modern nonprofit CRM focused on responsive fundraising and personalized donor journeys.
Platforms & Use Cases
Platforms: Web-based
Best For: Donor Management, Responsive Fundraising, Marketing Automation, Major Gift Tracking, Volunteer Management
Key Features
- ✓Responsive Fundraising: Uses data signals to suggest personalized outreach opportunities.
- ✓Marketing Automation: Build sophisticated, multi-step donor journeys.
- ✓Giving Analytics: Provides insights into donor behavior and identifies growth potential.
- ✓Project Management: Tools to track programs, grants, and major gift pipelines.
- ✓Modern Interface: Clean and intuitive user experience.
Scorecard (Overall: 8.1 / 10.0)
Pricing
Starter
$350.00 / Monthly
- Core CRM
- Email Marketing
- Online Giving
- Basic Automation
Limitations: Contact limits apply, Fewer advanced features
Platform
Contact Vendor
- Advanced Automation
- Project Management
- API Access
- Advanced Analytics
Limitations: Quote-based pricing
Pros
- + Focus on personalized donor journeys
- + Strong marketing automation features
- + Modern and intuitive interface
- + Good analytics capabilities
Cons
- - Higher price point, especially for smaller organizations
- - Relatively newer compared to some established players
Verdict
"Excellent choice for growth-focused nonprofits seeking a modern CRM with powerful marketing automation and personalization features."
#6
Blackbaud Raiser's Edge NXT
By Blackbaud
Industry-leading, comprehensive fundraising and donor management solution for large and complex nonprofits.
Platforms & Use Cases
Platforms: Web-based, iOS, Android
Best For: Advanced Donor Management, Major Gift Cultivation, Grant Management, Complex Fundraising Campaigns, Analytics and Prospect Research
Key Features
- ✓Robust CRM Capabilities: Deep functionality for tracking complex relationships and interactions.
- ✓Prospect Research Tools: Integrated tools for identifying and researching major gift prospects.
- ✓Advanced Analytics & Reporting: Powerful reporting engine with customizable dashboards and insights.
- ✓Workflow Automation: Automates tasks related to gift processing, acknowledgments, and stewardship.
- ✓Integrated Ecosystem: Connects with other Blackbaud products for finance, marketing, etc.
Scorecard (Overall: 8.1 / 10.0)
Pricing
NXT Package
Contact Vendor
- Core CRM
- Fundraising
- Reporting
- Analytics
- Prospect Tools
Limitations: Pricing is quote-based and generally high, Requires significant investment
Pros
- + Extremely powerful and feature-rich
- + Industry standard for large nonprofits
- + Excellent reporting and analytics
- + Strong prospect research capabilities
Cons
- - Very expensive
- - Steep learning curve and complex interface
- - Can be overkill for smaller organizations
- - Customer support experiences vary
Verdict
"The powerhouse solution for large, established nonprofits with complex fundraising operations and the budget to match."
#5
Salsa CRM
By Bonterra
Integrated platform combining CRM, online fundraising, marketing automation, and advocacy tools.
Platforms & Use Cases
Platforms: Web-based
Best For: Donor Management, Digital Marketing, Online Fundraising, Advocacy Campaigns, Peer-to-Peer Fundraising, Event Management
Key Features
- ✓Unified Constituent Profiles: 360-degree view of supporter interactions across channels.
- ✓Marketing Automation: Build automated email series and workflows.
- ✓Advocacy Tools: Features for running online petitions and targeted actions.
- ✓Peer-to-Peer Fundraising: Tools for supporters to create their own fundraising pages.
- ✓Smart Engagement Technology: Machine learning insights to optimize outreach (in higher tiers).
Scorecard (Overall: 7.0 / 10.0)
Pricing
Custom Package
Contact Vendor
- CRM
- Fundraising
- Marketing Automation
- Advocacy
- P2P
- Event Management
Limitations: Pricing is quote-based, depends on features and scale
Pros
- + Integrated suite of tools (CRM, marketing, advocacy)
- + Strong digital marketing and automation features
- + Good peer-to-peer fundraising capabilities
Cons
- - Can be complex to navigate
- - Pricing requires a custom quote and can be expensive
- - Acquisition by Bonterra led to some organizational changes
Verdict
"A powerful option for organizations heavily focused on digital marketing, multi-channel engagement, and advocacy, but may be complex for simpler needs."
#4
Little Green Light
By Little Green Light LLC
Affordable and straightforward donor management CRM designed primarily for small to mid-sized nonprofits.
Platforms & Use Cases
Platforms: Web-based
Best For: Donor Management, Fundraising, Appeal Management, Event Management, Reporting
Key Features
- ✓Constituent Management: Tracks donors, prospects, volunteers, and other relationships.
- ✓Gift Tracking: Manages donations, pledges, in-kind gifts, and soft credits.
- ✓Appeal Management: Tools to plan, execute, and track fundraising campaigns.
- ✓Customizable Forms: Build forms for donations, events, and volunteer sign-ups.
- ✓Integrations: Connects with popular tools like Mailchimp, PayPal, Stripe, QuickBooks.
Scorecard (Overall: 8.1 / 10.0)
Pricing
Up to 2,500 Constituents
$45.00 / Monthly
- All features included
- Unlimited Users
- Free Integrations
Limitations: Pricing based solely on constituent record count
Up to 5,000 Constituents
$60.00 / Monthly
- All features included
Limitations: Record count limit
Up to 10,000 Constituents
$80.00 / Monthly
- All features included
Limitations: Record count limit
Pros
- + Extremely affordable pricing model
- + Very easy to learn and use
- + Excellent customer support
- + Good selection of integrations
- + All features included in all plans
Cons
- - Less comprehensive feature set than larger platforms
- - Reporting is functional but not as powerful as some competitors
- - Limited native marketing automation
Verdict
"Outstanding value for small to mid-sized nonprofits needing a user-friendly and affordable donor management system."
#3
DonorPerfect
By SofterWare, Inc.
Long-standing, feature-rich CRM focused on fundraising and donor management with flexible pricing.
Platforms & Use Cases
Platforms: Web-based, iOS, Android
Best For: Donor Management, Fundraising, Grant Tracking, Event Management, Reporting, Payment Processing
Key Features
- ✓Comprehensive Donor Profiles: Tracks detailed constituent information and interaction history.
- ✓Integrated Payment Processing: Built-in tools for secure online and offline donation processing.
- ✓Reporting Suite: Extensive library of standard reports and options for custom reports.
- ✓Constant Contact Integration: Seamless integration for email marketing campaigns.
- ✓Mobile App: Allows access to donor data and basic functions on the go.
Scorecard (Overall: 7.7 / 10.0)
Pricing
Lite
$99.00 / Monthly
- Up to 1,000 Records
- Core CRM
- Basic Reporting
- Online Forms
Limitations: Limited features and integrations
Essentials
$179.00 / Monthly
- Up to 2,500 Records
- Integrated Payment Processing
- Standard Reports
Limitations: Based on record count
Premier
$499.00 / Monthly
- Up to 25,000 Records
- Advanced Reporting
- API Access
- All Features
Limitations: Based on record count
Pros
- + Robust fundraising features
- + Integrated payment processing
- + Scalable pricing based on contacts
- + Established platform with strong support
Cons
- - Interface can feel somewhat dated
- - Customization can require effort
- - Some advanced features cost extra
Verdict
"A solid, reliable choice for nonprofits focused on fundraising, offering scalability and deep feature sets."
#2
Neon CRM
By Neon One
Comprehensive, cloud-based platform covering CRM, fundraising, events, marketing, and website management.
Platforms & Use Cases
Platforms: Web-based
Best For: Donor Management, Fundraising, Event Management, Membership Management, Volunteer Tracking, Email Marketing, Website Builder
Key Features
- ✓All-in-One Platform: Combines various nonprofit management tools into a single system.
- ✓Workflow Automation: Automates tasks like acknowledgments and reminders.
- ✓Event Management: Tools for managing event registration, ticketing, and communication.
- ✓Membership Management: Features for tracking members, renewals, and benefits.
- ✓Custom Reporting: Flexible reporting tools to analyze data across modules.
Scorecard (Overall: 7.7 / 10.0)
Pricing
Essentials
$99.00 / Monthly
- Core CRM
- Fundraising Tools
- Basic Email
- Standard Reports
Limitations: Limited contacts/emails, Fewer advanced features
Impact
$199.00 / Monthly
- More Contacts
- Event Management
- Volunteer Tracking
- Advanced Reporting
Limitations: Contact limits define tiers
Empower
$399.00 / Monthly
- Highest Limits
- Workflow Automation
- Membership Management
- API Access
Limitations: Contact limits define tiers
Pros
- + Highly comprehensive feature set
- + Good workflow automation
- + Scalable for growing organizations
- + Strong integration capabilities
Cons
- - Can have a steeper learning curve
- - Interface can feel dated in some areas
- - Support quality can vary
Verdict
"Ideal for mid-sized to larger nonprofits needing a robust, all-in-one solution to manage diverse operations."
View Top Ranked Software
Watch a short ad to unlock the details for the #1 ranked software.
#1
Bloomerang
By Bloomerang
Focuses on donor retention and engagement through a user-friendly interface and actionable insights.
Platforms & Use Cases
Platforms: Web-based, iOS, Android
Best For: Donor Management (CRM), Online Fundraising, Email Marketing, Reporting, Volunteer Management
Key Features
- ✓Interactive Dashboard: Provides key metrics and engagement scores at a glance.
- ✓Donor Engagement Score: Proprietary score predicting likelihood of continued support.
- ✓Email Marketing Tools: Built-in tools for creating and sending targeted email campaigns.
- ✓Online Giving Forms: Customizable forms for donations and event registrations.
- ✓Reporting & Analytics: Generates reports on fundraising performance, donor behavior, and retention.
Scorecard (Overall: 8.0 / 10.0)
Pricing
Standard
$99.00 / Monthly
- Up to 1,000 Records
- Unlimited Users
- Email Marketing
- Online Giving
- Reporting
Limitations: Contact limits define pricing tiers
Pros
- + Excellent customer support
- + Focus on donor retention
- + User-friendly interface
- + Good core CRM features
Cons
- - Reporting could be more customizable
- - Higher starting price compared to some basic options
Verdict
"A top choice for nonprofits prioritizing donor retention and ease of use, particularly those looking for strong support."
Author information could not be loaded for this review.
Final Thoughts
The nonprofit software landscape offers diverse solutions catering to different organizational sizes, priorities, and budgets. Leading options range from comprehensive, all-in-one CRMs like Neon CRM and Raiser's Edge NXT to user-friendly, retention-focused platforms like Bloomerang, highly affordable options like Little Green Light, and specialized fundraising tools like Givebutter and Fundraise Up. Selection depends heavily on balancing feature needs, ease of use, integration requirements, and cost.