Top 10 Roofing Replacement Companies Reviewed
By Sheila Morgan | Published: 2024-07-27 | Category: Roofing Replacement Company
About Roofing Replacement Company
Roofing replacement involves removing the old roofing materials down to the deck and installing a completely new roofing system. This service is crucial for maintaining a building's structural integrity and protecting it from the elements.
How We Evaluated
Providers were evaluated based on customer satisfaction ratings, reported workmanship quality, warranty comprehensiveness, pricing practices, and the breadth of their service coverage. Publicly available data and company reputation were key factors in the assessment.
Rating Criteria
- → Customer Satisfaction
- → Workmanship Quality
- → Warranty Options
- → Pricing Transparency
- → Service Area Coverage
The Best Roofing Replacement Company
#10
Location: Plymouth, MN (HQ - Operates in Upper Midwest & expanding) Get Directions
Founded: 2011
Legacy Restoration
Visit Website →Specializes in exterior restoration services, particularly roofing, siding, and windows, often focusing on projects resulting from storm damage.
Target Audience
Residential Homeowners, Commercial Property Owners, Insurance Claims
Service Offerings
Roof Replacement
Installs asphalt shingles and other common residential roofing materials.
- Platinum Preferred Contractor with Owens Corning
- Expertise in storm damage assessment
Siding & Windows
Offers replacement services for siding and windows.
Scorecard (Overall: 7.2 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Estimate Required
Free inspections and estimates, particularly geared towards insurance claims. Financing available.
Pros
- + Strong manufacturer partnerships (Owens Corning Platinum)
- + Good reputation in its core markets
- + Expertise in handling insurance claims
- + Growing company
Cons
- - Service area is currently limited, primarily Upper Midwest focus
- - Younger company compared to some competitors
Verdict
"A reputable, growing contractor focused on quality installations and storm restoration, especially strong in the Upper Midwest."
Bone Dry Roofing
Visit Website →A family-owned business grown into a large regional company offering residential and commercial roofing, gutters, insulation, and masonry services.
Target Audience
Residential Homeowners, Commercial Property Owners
Service Offerings
Residential & Commercial Roofing
Installation, replacement, and repair of various roof types.
- Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor
Gutters & Insulation
Complementary services for a complete roof system approach.
Masonry
Chimney repair and other masonry work offered in many locations.
Scorecard (Overall: 7.8 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Estimate Required
Free estimates. Offers maintenance plans and financing.
Pros
- + Strong regional reputation
- + Family-owned values with large company resources
- + Wide range of services including masonry
- + High customer satisfaction scores
Cons
- - Service area limited to Midwest and Southeast
- - Not a nationwide provider
Verdict
"An excellent regional choice known for quality work and customer service, particularly strong in the Midwest."
Mr. Roof
Visit Website →A regional roofing company known for its efficient installation process ('Same-Day Installation' claim for many projects) and lifetime warranties.
Target Audience
Residential Homeowners
Service Offerings
Roof Replacement
Focus on asphalt shingle roofs, often aiming for single-day completion.
- Lifetime transferable warranty on premium systems
Windows, Siding, Gutters
Provides a range of exterior remodeling services.
Scorecard (Overall: 7.6 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Estimate Required
Free, no-obligation estimates. Financing options are available.
Pros
- + Potential for fast installation
- + Lifetime transferable warranty offered
- + Long company history
- + Multiple exterior services
Cons
- - 'Same-Day' promise may not apply to all projects
- - Service area limited to specific states in the Midwest and Southeast
- - Can be pricier due to speed and warranty
Verdict
"A good choice for homeowners in its service area prioritizing speed of installation and a comprehensive lifetime warranty."
#7
Location: Hillsboro, OR (HQ - Operates primarily West Coast & expanding) Get Directions
Founded: 2011
DaBella
Visit Website →A rapidly growing home improvement company focused on roofing, siding, windows, and bath replacements, emphasizing quality materials and customer service.
Target Audience
Residential Homeowners
Service Offerings
Asphalt Shingle Roofing
Installs GAF and Owens Corning roofing systems.
- Factory-certified installers
- Focus on system integrity
Other Exterior Services
Also offers siding, windows, and gutter replacement.
Scorecard (Overall: 7.4 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Project-Based
Free estimates provided via in-home consultation. Offers financing.
Pros
- + Uses quality materials from major brands
- + Strong manufacturer certifications
- + Good customer reviews in many locations
- + Offers multiple exterior services
Cons
- - Service area concentrated on the West Coast and select other states
- - Rapid growth can sometimes lead to operational challenges
- - Pricing can be on the higher end
Verdict
"A strong contender for homeowners within its growing service area, particularly those looking for recognized brands and certified installation."
Erie Home
Visit Website →A long-standing home improvement company specializing in durable products like metal roofing, windows, and basement waterproofing across many eastern and midwestern states.
Target Audience
Residential Homeowners
Service Offerings
Metal Roofing
Specializes in stamped-panel metal roofs resembling shingles, shakes, or tile.
- Focus on durability and lifetime warranty
- Energy Star rated options
Asphalt Roofing
Offers traditional asphalt shingle roofing options as well.
Scorecard (Overall: 7.4 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Project-Based
Requires in-home estimate. Known for offering long-term financing.
Pros
- + Specializes in durable metal roofing
- + Offers lifetime, limited transferable warranties
- + Long company history
- + Financing options available
Cons
- - Metal roofing can be significantly more expensive upfront
- - High-pressure sales tactics sometimes reported
- - Service area not fully national
Verdict
"A solid option for homeowners specifically interested in high-durability metal roofing with strong warranty backing, primarily in the Eastern/Midwestern US."
Tecta America
Visit Website →One of the largest commercial roofing contractors in the U.S., offering a full range of roofing services from installation to preventative maintenance.
Target Audience
Commercial Property Owners, Industrial Facilities, Property Managers
Service Offerings
Commercial Roof Replacement
Expertise in all major commercial roofing systems (TPO, EPDM, PVC, Modified Bitumen, Metal).
- Focus on safety and long-term performance
Roof Asset Management
Preventative maintenance programs and repair services.
Green Roofing
Installation of sustainable roofing options like cool roofs and solar.
Scorecard (Overall: 8.2 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Project-Based Bids
Customized proposals based on project scope and specifications. Service agreements available.
Pros
- + Extensive commercial roofing expertise
- + Nationwide network of operating units
- + Strong focus on safety and preventative maintenance
- + Offers advanced roofing solutions
Cons
- - Primarily focused on commercial, less emphasis on residential
- - Can be more bureaucratic than smaller firms
Verdict
"A leading choice for commercial and industrial roofing projects requiring national reach, deep technical expertise, and ongoing maintenance support."
CMR Construction & Roofing
Visit Website →A large, family-owned company with a national footprint, specializing in storm damage restoration for both residential and commercial properties.
Target Audience
Residential Homeowners, Commercial Property Owners, Insurance Claims
Service Offerings
Roofing Systems
Installation of various roofing types including asphalt, metal, tile, and flat roofs.
- Significant experience with storm damage restoration
- Emergency response services
Commercial Roofing
Services tailored to large-scale commercial and industrial projects.
Scorecard (Overall: 7.8 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Estimate Required
Free inspections and estimates. Works closely with insurance adjusters.
Pros
- + National service area
- + Specializes in storm damage and insurance claims
- + Handles large and complex projects
- + 24/7 emergency service
Cons
- - Some reports of inconsistent customer service
- - Aggressive sales tactics reported by some customers
Verdict
"A major player in storm restoration roofing across the country, suitable for those needing rapid response and insurance expertise."
Baker Roofing Company
Visit Website →A long-established roofing company providing comprehensive residential and commercial roofing services, known for its large scale and deep expertise.
Target Audience
Residential Homeowners, Commercial Property Owners, Industrial Facilities
Service Offerings
Residential Roofing
Replacement and repair of shingles, metal, slate, and tile roofs.
Commercial Roofing
Expertise in low-slope/flat roofing, coatings, and complex industrial projects.
Repair & Maintenance
Dedicated service departments for ongoing roof care.
Scorecard (Overall: 8.0 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Estimate Required
Detailed quotes provided after inspection. Offers maintenance plans.
Pros
- + Decades of experience
- + Wide range of services for both residential and commercial
- + Strong reputation for quality
- + Dedicated repair division
Cons
- - Service area primarily limited to the Southeastern US
- - May be less price-competitive than smaller outfits
Verdict
"A highly reputable and experienced choice, especially for complex projects or commercial properties within their service region."
Aspen Contracting, Inc.
Visit Website →A large national roofing contractor specializing in insurance restoration work due to storm damage, serving both residential and commercial clients.
Target Audience
Residential Homeowners, Commercial Property Owners, Insurance Claims
Service Offerings
Roof Replacement
Specializes in asphalt, metal, tile, and flat roofing replacement.
- Expertise in hail and wind damage
- Works directly with insurance companies
Siding and Gutters
Installation and replacement services often related to storm damage.
Scorecard (Overall: 8.2 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Estimate Required
Free inspections and estimates provided. Heavily involved in insurance claim pricing.
Pros
- + Nationwide coverage
- + Extensive experience with insurance claims
- + Offers various roofing materials
- + Strong 'Ironclad' warranty
Cons
- - Customer service experiences can vary by location
- - Focus on storm damage may mean less emphasis on standard retail replacements
Verdict
"Excellent option for property owners dealing with storm damage and needing assistance navigating the insurance claims process across the US."
View Top Ranked Provider
Watch a short ad to unlock the details for the #1 ranked provider.
Power Home Remodeling
Visit Website →One of the largest exterior home remodelers, offering roofing, windows, siding, and doors with a strong focus on customer experience and technology integration.
Target Audience
Residential Homeowners
Service Offerings
Asphalt Shingle Roofing
Installation of high-quality asphalt shingle roofing systems.
- Utilizes integrated roofing systems
- Focus on energy efficiency
Attic Insulation
Often bundled with roofing projects for improved home energy performance.
Scorecard (Overall: 8.4 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Project-Based
Requires in-home consultation for a detailed estimate. Financing options available.
Pros
- + Large service area
- + Strong emphasis on customer service
- + High-quality materials
- + Technology-driven process
Cons
- - Can be more expensive than smaller local competitors
- - Focus limited to specific exterior services
Verdict
"A top choice for homeowners seeking a comprehensive exterior remodeling experience with strong customer support and wide availability."
Final Recommendation
Choosing a roofing replacement company involves balancing national reach, specialized expertise (like storm damage or commercial projects), material options, warranty, and customer service reputation. Large national players offer broad coverage and often robust systems, while strong regional companies may provide more localized expertise and customer focus. Evaluating based on your specific needs—be it insurance assistance, specific materials like metal, or commercial scale—is key.