Top 10 Barber Shops for a Sharp Look
By Richard "Rick" Callahan | Published: 2025-03-15 | Category: Barbers
About Barbers
Barbershops specialize in hair cutting, styling, and grooming services primarily tailored for men, offering traditional and modern techniques. Services often include haircuts, shaves, beard trims, and other related grooming treatments.
How We Evaluated
Providers were selected based on analysis of customer satisfaction ratings, breadth of services offered, expertise of barbers, shop ambiance, and overall value proposition. Evaluations considered online reviews, service menus, and brand reputation across various locations.
Rating Criteria
- → Customer Service
- → Barber Skill
- → Ambiance
- → Value
- → Services Offered
The Best Barbers
Sloane Square Barbers & Shoppe
Visit Website →London-inspired barbershop offering traditional grooming services for gentlemen in a sophisticated environment.
Target Audience
Discerning men, Local professionals, Tourists seeking upscale grooming
Service Offerings
Gentleman's Haircut
Includes wash, cut, and style.
Traditional Hot Towel Shave
Classic straight razor shave.
Beard Reshaping
Detailed beard trim and shaping.
Grey Blending
Subtle hair color service.
Scorecard (Overall: 8.2 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Haircut
$55.00
Starting price for a gentleman's haircut.
Shave
$55.00
Starting price for a traditional shave.
Pros
- + Elegant and clean British-style decor
- + Professional and attentive service
- + Offers complimentary beverages
- + Good range of traditional services
Cons
- - Premium pricing
- - Appointments usually necessary
- - Single Location
Verdict
"A refined choice in Miami Beach for traditional men's grooming, providing excellent service in a sophisticated, relaxing setting."
The Art of Shaving
Visit Website →Retailer and barbershop focusing on premium shaving products and offering traditional barber services like shaves and haircuts.
Target Audience
Men interested in premium shaving, Gift shoppers, Those seeking traditional wet shaves
Service Offerings
Royal Shave
Signature multi-step hot towel shave experience.
Haircut
Traditional men's haircut.
Head Shave
Straight razor head shave.
Beard Trim
Facial hair grooming with premium products.
Scorecard (Overall: 7.2 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Royal Shave
$60.00
Approximate price, varies by location.
Haircut
$50.00
Approximate price, varies by location.
Pros
- + Specializes in high-quality shaves
- + Wide availability in retail centers
- + Sells premium grooming products
- + Focus on luxurious experience
Cons
- - Higher price point, especially for shaves
- - Barber skill can be inconsistent across locations
- - More focused on retail sales than some independent shops
Verdict
"Best known for its luxurious shave experiences and product line, offering convenient access to traditional barber services in many locations."
Belmont Barbershop Ltd.
Visit Website →A well-regarded Chicago barbershop known for its traditional services, skilled barbers, and classic Americana decor.
Target Audience
Men of all ages, Classic style enthusiasts, Local Chicago residents
Service Offerings
Haircut
Traditional and modern men's cuts.
Hot Lather Shave
Straight razor shave with hot towels.
Beard Trim
Shaping and trimming facial hair.
Scorecard (Overall: 8.0 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Haircut
$40.00
Approximate price for a haircut.
Shave
$40.00
Approximate price for a shave.
Pros
- + Experienced and talented barbers
- + Classic, inviting atmosphere
- + Reasonable pricing for the quality
- + Strong local reputation
Cons
- - Walk-ins may face long waits
- - Can get busy
- - Primarily focused on traditional barbering
Verdict
"A solid Chicago institution for quality traditional barbering in a classic, friendly setting."
Acme Barbershop
Visit Website →Traditional barbershop focusing on high-quality classic men's cuts and shaves in a relaxed setting.
Target Audience
Men seeking classic cuts, Local residents, Traditionalists
Service Offerings
Haircut
Classic men's haircuts.
Straight Razor Shave
Traditional hot towel shave service.
Beard Trim
Beard shaping and maintenance.
Scorecard (Overall: 8.2 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Haircut
$45.00
Approximate price for a haircut.
Shave
$45.00
Approximate price for a shave.
Pros
- + Expertise in classic barbering
- + Friendly and professional service
- + Clean and comfortable atmosphere
- + Good value for the quality
Cons
- - Primarily focused on traditional styles
- - Appointments highly recommended
- - Single Location
Verdict
"A top-notch traditional barbershop delivering excellent classic cuts and shaves with great service."
Frank's Chop Shop
Visit Website →Iconic Lower East Side barbershop known for its classic atmosphere, celebrity clientele, and traditional barbering services.
Target Audience
Traditionalists, Streetwear enthusiasts, Downtown NYC locals
Service Offerings
Haircut
Classic men's haircuts.
Straight Razor Shave
Hot towel shave.
Beard Trim
Facial hair grooming.
Scorecard (Overall: 7.8 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Haircut
$50.00
Starting price for a standard cut.
Shave
$50.00
Starting price for a shave.
Pros
- + Authentic, old-school vibe
- + Highly experienced barbers
- + Strong reputation and history
- + Cultural hub in the LES
Cons
- - Can be busy, appointments recommended
- - Cash only (traditionally, may have changed)
- - Single location
Verdict
"A legendary NYC barbershop offering expert traditional services in an authentic, no-frills environment."
#5
Location: Multiple locations including Seattle, Portland, Los Angeles, New York, Atlanta Get Directions
Founded: 1993
Rudy's Barbershop
Visit Website →Casual, inclusive barbershop known for its laid-back vibe, support for the arts, and straightforward services.
Target Audience
Men, Women, Creative types, All ages
Service Offerings
Haircut
Cuts for all genders and hair types.
Buzz Cut
Simple clipper cut.
Color Services
Basic color options available at some locations.
Beard Trim
Maintenance for facial hair.
Scorecard (Overall: 7.2 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Haircut
$45.00
Approximate starting price, varies by location and stylist level.
Pros
- + Relaxed and welcoming atmosphere
- + Inclusive environment
- + Online booking available
- + Consistent branding and experience
Cons
- - No traditional shave services
- - Skill level can vary between stylists
- - Prices have increased over time
Verdict
"A cool, casual spot known for its unfussy approach to hair and welcoming vibe, good for straightforward cuts."
Floyd's 99 Barbershop
Visit Website →Rock 'n' roll themed barbershop chain offering a full range of services for men and women in a high-energy environment.
Target Audience
Men, Women, Families, Music Fans
Service Offerings
Haircuts
Cuts for various styles and lengths.
Color Services
Hair coloring options.
Shaves
Traditional straight razor shaves.
Waxing
Facial waxing services.
Scorecard (Overall: 7.8 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Floyd's Cut
$35.00
Average price for standard men's cut, varies by location.
Shave
$35.00
Average price for standard shave, varies by location.
Pros
- + Wide range of services including color
- + Fun, energetic atmosphere
- + Accepts walk-ins
- + Moderate pricing
- + Many convenient locations
Cons
- - Service quality can vary by location/stylist
- - Can be noisy
- - Experience may feel less personalized than independent shops
Verdict
"A reliable and widely accessible option offering good value and a broad service menu in a lively, music-filled setting."
#3
Location: Multiple locations including New York City, Los Angeles, Chicago, Philadelphia, Miami Get Directions
Founded: 2010
Blind Barber
Visit Website →Unique concept combining a barbershop with a speakeasy-style bar in the back. Offers quality cuts, shaves, and cocktails.
Target Audience
Young Professionals, Social Crowd, Men seeking a unique experience
Service Offerings
Haircut
Includes wash and style.
Shave
Hot towel straight razor shave.
Beard Trim
Beard shaping and cleanup.
Hangover Treatment
Shave or Trim combined with facial massage elements.
Scorecard (Overall: 8.2 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Haircut
$55.00
Approximate starting price, varies by location.
Shave
$55.00
Approximate starting price, varies by location.
Pros
- + Unique bar/barbershop concept
- + Vibrant, social atmosphere
- + Complimentary cocktail with service
- + Skilled barbers
Cons
- - Can be loud and busy
- - Prices higher than average
- - Atmosphere may not suit everyone
Verdict
"A great spot for a quality cut paired with a unique social experience, especially appealing to a younger, trend-conscious clientele."
Baxter Finley Barber & Shop
Visit Website →Upscale, appointment-only barbershop from the Baxter of California grooming brand. Focuses on classic cuts and shaves.
Target Audience
Discerning Gentlemen, Fans of Baxter of California products
Service Offerings
Cut & Style
Classic and modern haircuts.
Straight Razor Shave
Hot towel shave service.
Beard Trim
Beard maintenance and shaping.
Scorecard (Overall: 8.4 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Haircut
$70.00
Starting price for a haircut.
Shave
$70.00
Starting price for a shave.
Pros
- + Exceptional ambiance and design
- + Top-tier barbers with expertise in classic styles
- + Integration with Baxter of California products
- + Personalized service
Cons
- - Premium pricing
- - Appointment only, limited availability
- - Single location
Verdict
"A luxurious grooming destination offering meticulous service and a sophisticated atmosphere, ideal for those seeking a classic high-end experience."
View Top Ranked Provider
Watch a short ad to unlock the details for the #1 ranked provider.
#1
Location: Multiple locations including New York City and Los Angeles Get Directions
Founded: 2006
Fellow Barber
Visit Website →Modern barbershop experience blending traditional techniques with contemporary style. Known for its curated grooming products.
Target Audience
Modern Men, Style-Conscious Individuals
Service Offerings
Haircut
Standard haircut service.
- Consultation
- Cut
- Style
Buzz Cut
Single-guard all over.
Shave
Traditional hot towel straight razor shave.
Beard Trim
Shaping and trimming of beard.
Scorecard (Overall: 8.4 / 10.0)
Pricing Model
Haircut
$60.00
Approximate starting price, varies by location.
Shave
$60.00
Approximate starting price, varies by location.
Pros
- + Highly skilled barbers
- + Stylish and clean ambiance
- + Offers own line of quality grooming products
- + Consistent service across locations
Cons
- - Higher price point
- - Appointments often needed far in advance
Verdict
"Excellent choice for a premium, modern barbershop experience with skilled professionals and a great atmosphere."
Final Recommendation
The barbering landscape offers diverse options, from modern, multi-location shops like Fellow Barber and Blind Barber known for their unique ambiances, to deeply traditional, single-location institutions like Frank's Chop Shop and Acme. Chains like Floyd's 99 provide accessibility and broader service ranges including color, while specialists like The Art of Shaving focus on premium shave experiences. Quality and atmosphere vary, but top contenders prioritize skilled barbers and excellent customer service.